I perused a library, its young adult section brimming with books. Books set in the past and future, but mostly set in fictional universes in which our hero discovers she/he is the Chosen with great powers and given some important purpose.
(Here is ChatGPT's cover to a "YA novel in a medieval fantasy world with a teen who is the Chosen One)In that they are not wrong. In fact, the cliche works because there is so much truth in it. It resonates with some part of the unjaded little souls because the resonant frequency programmed into them senses some truth.
Each of us is breathed in by the Breath of God, created for a mission and a calling, sent forth into a world at war between Evil and Good. Evil beyond our comprehension and Good beyond our wildest imagining.
But what struck me was how young a lot of the authors looked in their back-jacket pictures. It may be simply photoshop or judicious use of sunscreen, but a lot of those authors looked to be in their twenties. In your twenties, writing books that teens read that will shape their understanding of the structure of reality.
As far as the book-jackets could show, these young authors didn't seem to be war veterans, or peace-keepers from soup kitchens, coming out of the trenches of war or humanitarian aid, with lots to tell of what they had seen. A lot of them seemed like just young people themselves who gathered their ideas about the world from other young adult novels they had spent the last decade reading.
The serpent is eating its tail.
The AI is creating answers based on its own answers.
The computer program is stuck in a loop, recursively spitting out its cyclic version of reality.
George R. Martin, comic book nerd and draft dodger, tells other comic book nerds what true gritty war is like, from a lifetime of consuming novels and comic books.
In contrast, by the time J.R.R Tolkien wrote The Hobbit he had fought in a world war, grieved his best friends, convinced his teenage crush to marry him, held down a job interacting with other humans, raised 4 kids, and then was sending The Hobbit in chapters to encourage his son fighting another world war.
He had seen a lot. He had experienced a lot. He had interacted with others who had experienced a lot.
He'd lived.
(It's possible George R Martin maybe based his stories on actual stories of his fellow men who did go and fight in wars that he didn't believe in. I don't know, I haven't read his novels. I know he did consume a vast amount of fiction & comics, by his own account. But if I had a choice of hearing about war from the minstrel, or the soldier, I'd rather pick the soldier. Guns Up or something by a man of George's generation who actually fought)
When people write to escape their lives, their works by definition are all conjecture. The brain must draw on something.
The Bronte sisters, stuck on the moor in a small village, consuming a lot of gothic novels, wrote of what they didn't know. Thus we have fantastical stories woven mostly of threads from other gothic novels, forgettable works like Emily Bronte's "Wuthering Heights" which felt like sticking my head into an AI simulator or a surreal nightmare. A simulator in which an introverted pastor's daughter wrote what she thought it might be like to be embroiled in a tormented paranormal gothic romance.
And then we have her sister Charlotte's more enduring "Jane Eyre" in which she blends a lot more of her own experience into the gothic nightmare. Now we have a very real childhood friendship as one of them dies of consumption (her sister), the warm mission-minded family with the driven Greek-studying boy in love with the idea of India, the gossipy maid, the real people woven into the strange nightmare. And thus, Jane Eyre has just enough realism in it to maybe make the gothic nightmare worth it.
Then there is Jane Austen, another nerdy pastor's daughter, who in her own words "writes on 2 inches of ivory." She knew she was limited to write what she knew, and she did it so well that those people she knew still come to life in her pages. You can even chart the same characters, as she looks back on them with older eyes, change and morph throughout her novels. I found her "Pride and Prejuidice" penned at 21, to have the flattest characters. Her later books, reincarnations of those same characters become every more deeper. She finally forgives Mrs. Bennet and gives her a whole book as the protoganist (Emma).
L. M. Montgomery's genius was writing her own village church people....Anne of Green Gables, Rilla of Ingleside...all the side characters, all the real people she wove into her stories....now, nearly 200 years later I can love her nosy neighbor, and laugh and cry over the struggles of this small town in the throes of being the homefront in WWI. The most forgettable of her stories are the ones I suspect she strayed most from her lived experience "Anne's House of Dreams", where as the romantic writer proposes to the girl with the floorlength hair of swirling gold, it feels like we really have wandered into one of Anne's dreams. Give me Ken and Rilla's awkward date on the porch while Old Susan crashes the party and starts sharing embarrassing stories of them as children. One of those scenes felt so much realer, because I would bet $100, it was.
Can young people write good books, my son asks? Is it required to actually live everything you write about? No. Tolkien didn't become king, or destroy a ring of power.
But on some level the stories (and people) we write must come from somewhere.
- Your life of the life of someone you know [primary]
- The life of someone else who wrote about it [secondary]
- The novel of someone you hope got it from reality, or at least, another novel based in reality.
Obviously, even 1 & 2 have some level of distortion, in that we are interpreting reality all the time, trying to make sense of it. That's what writing is.
Books about reality
In no particular order
Autobiographies---Primary Sources
- The Word Came with Power
- Search for the Source by Neil T.
Anderson
- ?Mission Possible by Marilyn Lazlo
- Guns Up, Johnnie M Clark
- ??Korean War book
- ?book by Amy Carmichal? Mimosa?
- The Cross and the Switchblade
- Through the Valley of the Kwai
- Guadalcanal Diary
- Laura Ingalls Wilder books, Farmer
Boy
- Caddie Woodlawn
- First 2 Ralph Moody Books [Little
Britches, Man of the Family]
- Water by the Inch
- Cheaper by the Dozen
- The Hiding Place
- ?Surviving the Angel of Death by
Eva Moses Kor
- ?Leap into Darkness, by Leo
Bretholz
- ?Diary of Anne Frank
- With God in Solitary
Confinement/In God’s Underground/With Christ in the communist prisons
- Pastor’s Wife
- Between Hammer and Sickle by Mihai Wurmbrand
- If Prison Walls Could Speak
- ?Gulag Archipelago
- Son of Hamas
- Seeking Allah, Finding Jesus
- ??Unbroken, Louis Zamperini
- Joker One
- Guns Up by Johnnie M. Clark
- The Search for the Source by Neil Andersen
- ????Daylight must come.
- ????The insanity of God
Biographies
- Joan of Arc: Her Story by Regine Pernoud
- Kit Carson by Ralph Moody
- ?Christopher coulubus by
Fernando Aresto
- ?Mary Lincoln by Ruth Painter
Randall
- ?William Wilberforce, by Eric Metaxes
- William Wilberforce by Belmonte
- ???TO the golden shore,
[adoniram Judson] by Courtney Anderson
- Never Say Die (Gladys Aylward) by
Cyril Davies
- Sundar Singh by Cyril Davies
- Vanya: A True Story by Myrna Grant
Epics & Legends & Ballads
- Illiad & Odyssey
- Beowulf
- Song of Roland
- Silmarillion
- The Lord of the Rings
- George MacDonald The Golden Key
- Fairy tales (Lang, irish one, etc)
- ???Viking Sagas???
- Demon Lover, Wanderer, [Medieval Ballads]
- Ballad of the White Horse
Novels
- All the Trailblazer books (Dave
and Neta Jackson) especially “Bandit of Asheley Downs” and “Listen for the
Whippoorwill” and “Captured by the River Rats”
- God King by Joanne Williamson
- The Lantern Bearers by Rosemary Sutcliff
- Narnia Books CS Lewis
- CS Lewis’ space trilogy
- Till We Have Faces by CS Lewis
- The Lord of the Rings & The Hobbit by JRR Tolkien
- Roll of Thunder, Hear my cry
- To Kill a Mockingbird
- Tell me a riddle, by Tillie Olsen
- Chesterton’s Father Brown
Mysteries, Four Faultess Felons, Man Who Was Thursday
- George MacDonald something
- Bronze Bow by Elisabeth George Speare
- Rolf and the Viking Bow by Allen French
- Cry the Beloved Country
- Crime and Punishment
- Number the Stars
- Allegiance & Choices of One by Timothy Zahn [Star Wars]
- [The Giver]
- Anne of Green Gables series by L. M. Montgomery
- Little Women by Louisa May Alcott
- Pride and Prejudice, Sense and Sensibility, and Emma etc by Jane Austen
- Enemy Brothers by Constance Savery
- Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain
- Mark Twain's Joan of Arc
- ?Jane Eyre? mixed feelings on this. It's a Christian response to a gothic novel, but it's still a gothic novel....my favorite characters die
- ???Starship Troopers
- ????something by Isaac Asimov?
- The Eight Arrow
- Strangers and Sojourners & Plague Journal by Michael D. O'Brien
- Sophia House by Michael D. O'Brien
MORE BOOK RECCOMENDATIONS from a friend. ( I haven't read all of these yet)
For kids and teens to read:
Peter Rabbit
Charlotte's Web
Trumpet of the Swan
Tom Sawyer
Little Women
Little Men (others if desired, Jo's Boys, Eight Cousins, and Old Fashioned Girl are among the next best)
Alice in Wonderland
Through the Looking Glass
Mrs. Frisby and Rats of Nihm
Treasures of the Snow, other St. John
Peter Pan
The Secret Garden
The Little Princess
Treasure Island, other Stevenson
Mother Goose
Aesop's Fables
Heidi
Robin Hood, Arthur, myths, fairy tales
Sherlock Holmes
Father Brown
Caddie Woodlawn
(Black Beauty)
(Black Stallion)
The Princess and the Goblin
The Princess and Curdie
Narnia
Hobbit/LotR
Wind in the Willows
Old Yeller
Where the Red Fern Grows
Little House on the Prairie
Phantom Tollbooth
Just So Stories or other Kipling
Winnie the Pooh
Sarah, Plain and Tall
Skylark (other sequels, too, if interested)
Little Britches
The Great Brain
Penderwicks and sequels
Anything by Robert McCloskey
Dr. Doolittle?
(Pinocchio)
The Railway Children, other Nesbit
Pollyanna
Witch of Blackbird Pond
Cheaper by the Dozen
Boxcar Children, first 19 only
Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys? At least one each
Sadako and the 1000 Cranes
Frindle, other by Clements if desired
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Anne of Green Gables, sequels and others if interested
Christmas Carol
Scarlet Pimpernel
All of a Kind Family
Brighto of the Grand Canyon, other Henry if interested
Captain's Courageous
Johnny Tremain
The Bible
The Westing Game
Little Pilgrim's Progress by Taylor
Original American Girl books
Chronicles of Prydain
The Little Engine that Could
Velveteen Rabbit
Wizard of Oz
101 Dalmatians
Mary Poppins
Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
Carry on Mr Bowditch
My Side of the Mountain
Call of the Wild
White Fang
Incredible Journey
Tale of Despereaux
Jules Verne
Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm
Understood Betsy
Older kids (~10+):
Huckleberry Finn
Jane Eyre
Watership Down
Roll of Thunder, Hear my Cry
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
Other C.S. Lewis
Cry, the Beloved Country
Any Jane Austen
Tale of Two Cities
Anne Frank
Ender's Game
Pilgrim's Progress
Agatha Christie
Dorothy Sayers
Robinson Crusoe
Swiss Family Robinson
To Kill a Mockingbird
Three Musketeers
Count of Monte Cristo
Crime and Punishment
Frankenstein
Shakespeare
Gulliver's Travels
Importance of Being Earnest, other Wilde
The Giver and sequels
1984
(Animal Farm)
Brave New World
Lord of the Flies
The Great Gatsby
(Grapes of Wrath)
Uncle Tom's Cabin
The Scarlet Letter
(North and South) I've read another by her that was good.
Cranford
Pygmalion (My Fair Lady)
(Last of the Mohicans)
00000000000000
recommended by random ppl on the internet
Gay girl good God (Jackie Hill Perry)
Prison saved my life (Louis Dooley and Heidi Gruber O'Very
The Insanity of God (Nik Rripken)
Patrick of Ireland (Michael AG Haykin)
?????https://www.kevinhalloran.net/best-christian-biographies/ literally googled this, have no idea who this guy is