Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Shotgun marriages & the Hobbit: What is love?


Sometimes when thinking about the human race, I feel like we're crafted together by an intelligent alien, saying, hmmmm, how can I get these selfish mortals to learn what love is?

I think it is what we spend our whole lives doing. Then looking back, we will finally realize how we were led, step by step, with the cords of human kindness, with bonds of love, as God stooped down to feed us, taking us by the arms, teaching us how to walk.

So he gave us sexual desires and dubious mental states of falling in love....He made us mammals whom release bonding oxytocin in our brains when we mate and when we lactate our infants....He lets us grow up more and deal with the hard parts of ourselves and our beloved, travails of raising teenagers, mid-life crisis, menopause, dark family secrets unearthed....Bit by bit He adjusts the factors of our lives. Hard times come...challenges we would have balked at if we'd foreseen them. But all of it, is carefully tuned in the hand of God, as he leads us by the arms, teaching us to walk.

All with the goal of teaching us to truly love.


"There goes my future and my life" by Kenny Chesney

Greatest country song ever "There Goes My Life" by Kenny Chesney and the music video version here

Even something beginning ignomiously as teens getting pregnant in high-school, may become something so beautiful.  I'm not saying that hormonal teenage shenanigans are love. I'm saying, it may become love. If we let God take the graphite dust of our lives, and turn it to diamonds.

My kids have taught my hard heart to love. Like a little seed falling into a rock, growing, cracking the rock with its little roots. Making room in a stingy and hard heart.

Kids teach us how to love.

Marriage teaches us how to love, what love is actually.

But what love ever starts out selfless and beautiful like Christ's? Most love starts out with self-interest. Cute girl laughed at his jokes. Cute baby thinks I'm a god. Love starts out making sense. Rational

We are being *conformed* into the image of Christ.

I think Love is something we use the word for all sorts of things.

The line between lust and love isn't a black n white line. Its a gradient with black on one side and white on one side.

What Christian groom ever said to his bride "I have no sexual desire for you, but decided to marry you because of your soul. I shall fulfill my conjugal duties because Scripture requires it."

Half, if not all, the marriage stories I hear start out "I noticed this cute girl in my class" or "the cute boy laughed at my jokes", or "he liked playing Zelda games", or "she had a good sense of humor", or "she was really hot", or "he could do parkour" or "she wrote such an interesting facebook post on criticizing the Prince Caspian movie...."

...yeah....so not necessarily the deepest soul-piercing reasons.

God works with this.

He takes our selfish human desires and spins gold out of straw.

Yes, love is kind of a trick. Starts out with the swelling music and the hormones and glimpses of incredible beauty of the other's soul. It doesn't take into account, the pettiness, the bitterness the 30s brings to the surface, the bad decisions, the childhood trauma working outwards, the marriage furnace that is menopause, the diagnosis, the tragedies.

If we saw the future, a lot of us would be too afraid to jump. Too scared. Too rational. Too selfish.

But if we saw the end---the very end, the soul refined joy and glory, and...love...

Would we jump?  Would we recognize the glory beyond the horror and pain, for the joy set before us, endure the suffering....In our fragile young pain-averse state, would we choose it?

I think so many of us would have run away at the altar if they knew the trials waiting...we imagine something difficult.... 


....but not even a fraction of what we were actually signing up for. 



Thank God we didn't know what they were getting into.

Like one of my favorite mommy bloggers, in her mid-twenties being told to go to a singles Biblestudy by her parents. And she went and noticed a cute boy in a Marine shirt. Cute. Faithful to God. Military shirt. All plusses. She chased him and they got married.

If as her eye scanned that room at the incoming singles, she had known it would be only 18 years and that over half of that would be chemo and suffering.... If she knew that she would bury him and have to finish raising the kids without him.....would her twenty-something year old self have done it? I don't think I would have. I would have run in terror.

But now, looking back, I know she wouldn't have traded it for anything.

On some level, all falling in love is really our subconscious calculating future-potential-happiness. (I mean, wouldn't it be disturbing if it was the opposite? If someone chose to marry someone because they found them annoying/misery-inducing/maximizing future unhappiness, it would be kind of messed up. 

[[Caveat: I know there are a very small percentage of boys who will marry a girl who makes them unhappy on purpose. [and vice versa] But even for this small statistic, I think the self-interested rule still applies. Because it seems to be relying on the catharsis of the rescue, and perhaps even some sort of role-as-rescuer. They see the future as better (the girl/boy will be rescued). There is a psychological payoff for doing it. It yields greater future happiness]]

When people get married, there's a lot of calculating & hoping for future happiness. As it should be. 

What is love?  Mutual admiration, enjoying the others company, happy warm fuzzies, and even a subconscious calculation of future happiness, with whiffs of the promise of love, this thing we mortals don't fully even articulate or understand.

I used to look down on guys for not being interested in girls who were obese...

or girls who talked about potential husbands earning potential....

"So shallow" my eighteen-year-old-self sniffed. But I failed to see how it was data in their calculations of future projected happiness. (e.g. If she hates her body and drops dead from hypertension, it puts a damper on things. If he's an artist, and she realizes she'll be working as a waitress to support the family it puts a damper on pursuing her own dreams etc, etc....)

Everyone has hopes and dreams for the future. And our dreams are, by definition, somewhat self centered. 

I realized later, as an 18 yr old I was also doing that. Love for LOTR was a deal-breaker for me. I didn't want to spend the next 75 yrs with someone who didn't love Tolkien...that wrecked my future hopes of happiness. 

So we all on some level are calculating and hoping for future happiness, when we get married.

But God works with this. He works with our less-than-idealistic reasons for marriage, with shallow reasons, and prideful reasons, and selfish reasons, and twitter-pated reasons, and even lustful reasons. 

He can make something holy and unselfish and very beautiful by the end.

He will teach us to love, even if we got into marriage for silly reasons. 

 Like Bilbo signing up to go an adventure mostly because the dwarves insulted him. It was wounded pride.... He wanted to show them wrong ("grocer indeed!")

So he went.

Bilbo regretted it a lot, when the trolls got him by the toes, when he was struggling in a river on a barrel, when stuck in a tree on fire,, when in the dark with Gollum, when walking down a dark hallway into a dragons den.

But in the end, he was glad he went. It was worth it.

If he had known what it meant on that may morning, he wouldn't have signed up.

But he went, he rode on eagles, he helped Thorin repent, he helped (though he never knew it) Bard slay the dragon. He learned to love difficult dwarves, he met elves, he saved a gold-mad Thorin from starting a dwarven/men war.

And he even ended up helping save the world from Sauron. 

All that didn't happen because Bilbo joined with the right motives.


It happened because he went. And God made something out of it.